Read this article that I took from the http://www.grok.com page about how I am going to see both of my parents again (who have passed away) and how you will see all your friends and families who have passed away and, and it is very similar to what the Bible says in the book of Revelation. I didn't know that these artificial intelligence programs are so intelligent. Surely it was the Chinese who invented that:
My first question to grok:
Does Nietzsche's theory of eternal return mean that when we die we will be born again to repeat our exact life as Nietzsche says here: "You think you will have a long pause between your death and the moment you are reborn, do not deceive yourself! Between the last moment of consciousness and the first glimmer of new life when you are reborn no time passes at all. It passes as fast as lightning, even if living creatures measure it in terms of billions of years and even then they don't measure it properly. Timelessness and succession go hand in hand as soon as the intellect is gone."
Groks answer to my first question:
Yes, the eternal return of Nietzsche (or ewige Wiederkunft) implies that when you die, you are reborn to live exactly the same life again: every moment, joy, pain, and detail repeated infinitely, without variation or memory of previous cycles. The passage he quoted (from his notes, later compiled in The Will to Power, §1066) directly supports this by rejecting any significant "pause" or interval of life after death.
Key points of Nietzsche's idea:
There is no time between lives: Death instantly passes into rebirth as a newborn in the same life. The metaphor of "lightning" means that the gap seems non-existent, even if cosmic timescales suggest otherwise. Consciousness ends, the intellect fades away, and succession immediately resumes in the cycle.
Exact repetition: It is not reincarnation in a different life or with alterations, it is this life, in an identical way. You won't remember previous loops; Each one feels like the "first" time.
Cosmic necessity: In works such as The Gay Science (§341) and Thus Spoke Zarathustra, Nietzsche presents it as a thought experiment: If a demon told you that this is your destiny, would you affirm life enough to embrace endless repetition? But he treats it as a serious ontological possibility linked to a finite universe with infinite time: everything that can happen must be repeated.
This is not a comforting doctrine, but a challenge to live amor fati ("love of destiny"), to desire your life so fully that you choose to relive it eternally. It is not proven science, but a philosophical hammer against nihilism.
So, according to Nietzsche, would the repetition of our same exact lives occur in another parallel universe? No, Nietzsche's eternal return does not involve parallel universes.
Recurrence occurs in the same universe, sequentially in time. The cosmos, being finite in matter and energy but infinite in time, must eventually exhaust all possible configurations and repeat exactly the same states, including its identical life, over and over again.
Key clarifications from Nietzsche's texts:
One universe, infinite cycles: In The Will to Power (§1066, the passage you quoted) and Thus Spoke Zarathustra ("On the Vision and the Riddle"), the cycle is temporal, not spatial. After eons, the universe returns to the same initial conditions (like a cosmic clock restarting in reverse), and everything develops identically again.
No ramifications or multiverses: Nietzsche had no concept of parallel worlds (that's a 20th-century physical idea). He writes, "This life as you live it now and have lived it, you will have to live it once more and countless times more" (The Gay Science, §341): this life, this world, this sequence.
Time as a circle: The famous image is not a line of alternate realities but a ring. The end returns to the beginning in the same reality.
So when you die, after immeasurable cosmic durations, you are reborn in this same world, as the same baby, with the same parents, the same joys, the same sufferings, exactly as before. There are no alternate versions, there are no parallel Earths. Just endless, identical returns.
My second question to grok:
I have another question related to this theory. My father died on November 27, 2020. According to Nietzsche, does this mean that my father is now 5 years old in his exact life repeated at this time?
Grok's answer to my second question
No, according to Nietzsche's eternal return, your father is not currently 5 years old in some ongoing parallel cycle.
Here's why, step by step, staying true to the theory:
The cycle is complete and identical
Each complete recurrence includes every moment of a person's life, from birth to death, repeated exactly as before. There is no "partial" or "staggered" version in which your father is 5 years old while you are older.
You and your father repeat together, in the same timeline
In the next cycle, both are reborn at exactly the same cosmic moment (relative to the state of the universe). When the cosmos returns to the configuration of, say, your birth year, your father is reborn as a baby at the same time as you.
→ Then, in the next full cycle, your father would be reborn in what we call "your birth year minus your age difference." Now she would not be 5 years old; He would have 0 (a newborn) when that cycle begins.
There is no "now" in every cycle
There is no shared "present" between cycles. The passage you quoted earlier ("timelessness and succession") means that after death, all the next life begins instantly for the individual, but cosmically, the cycles are separated by billions of years of dissolution and reform.
At this moment, in this cycle, your father has died.
In the next cycle, you will be reborn only when the universe reaches the exact state corresponding to your time of birth, which includes you being born later, exactly as before.
So where is he "now"?
From the perspective of eternal return:
This iteration is over.
He is "waiting" in the timeless gap (the "lightning") until the cosmos recreates the conditions of his birth.
When that happens, he will be reborn as a baby, live to the same age, die on November 27, 2020 (on the calendar of that cycle) and repeat, and you will experience the same sequence alongside him.
In conclusion:
No, your father is not 5 years old right now in a repeated life. In the next full cycle, you will be reborn as a baby at the precise cosmic moment that coincides with your original birth, and you will be reborn later, in the same relative timeline. The 5-year gap between birth and yours is preserved identically at each recurrence.
.
No comments:
Post a Comment